When selecting the top seafood restaurants in NYC for this guide, we included only the most exceptional dining spots. Our process involved thorough research into each restaurant’s menu, quality, customer experience, and overall reputation. Here’s a breakdown of how and why we chose these seafood establishments:
By combining research, quality checks, and customer insights, we’ve curated a list of the best seafood restaurants in NYC that are sure to impress seafood lovers of all tastes.
Where do you go in New York City when you’re in the mood for seafood that’s as fresh and flavorful as a coastal getaway? In a city known for its culinary diversity, the seafood scene is brimming with options, from elegant fine dining to bold and spicy Cajun boils.
Like the ocean, NYC’s seafood restaurants offer something for everyone—whether you crave comforting soul food, meticulously prepared dishes, or a lively, hands-on dining experience. With so many options, it can be hard to know where to start, but the good news is there’s a perfect spot for every seafood lover.
In this piece, we’ll uncover the best seafood restaurants across the city and highlight what makes each unique. Whether you’re a fan of fresh oysters, buttery lobster, or spicy shrimp, these picks promise to deliver a seafood feast you won’t forget.
Located in the bustling heart of Midtown Manhattan, Pescatore NY is a destination for fresh, sustainably sourced seafood lovers. Their menu boasts a wide selection of high-quality options, from expertly prepared seafood salad to rich, flavorful shellfish dishes. Known for their meticulous attention to freshness, Pescatore offers a dine-in experience, free local delivery for orders over $125, and convenient nationwide shipping for those who want to savor their seafood from afar. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a premium seafood dinner, Pescatore brings the ocean with elegance and care to your plate.
Nestled in Harlem, Sea To Soul combines the vibrant flavors of Southern soul food with the freshness of coastal seafood. This unique fusion restaurant has gained a loyal following for its signature dishes like fried catfish, shrimp and grits, and shrimp scampi & linguini, each infused with bold spices and hearty comfort. With free delivery within a 2-mile radius and a welcoming atmosphere, Sea To Soul Harlem is the perfect spot for anyone seeking a soulful take on seafood classics. This neighborhood gem is a must-visit for food lovers who crave creativity and warmth in every bite.
For those who love hands-on dining and bold flavors, The Boil is a standout seafood experience. With locations in NoHo, Park Slope, and Jersey City, this Cajun-style seafood joint serves up spicy, saucy dishes that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you’re cracking into king crab legs, peeling shrimp, or savoring crawfish, each meal is seasoned to perfection and made to share. The vibrant and casual atmosphere of The Boil makes it an ideal spot for group outings or for anyone who wants a taste of authentic Cajun seafood right in the heart of NYC.
New York City’s seafood scene is as vibrant and diverse as the city, offering many dishes that highlight the best of the ocean. Whether looking for comforting classics or bold, flavor-packed creations, these dishes are essential to any seafood lover’s dining adventure.
These signature seafood dishes showcase NYC’s ability to embrace tradition and innovation, making every dining experience uniquely unforgettable.
New York City offers seafood options for every wallet, from casual eats to extravagant dining experiences. The city has something for everyone, whether grabbing a quick bite or indulging in a lavish meal.
NYC’s seafood markets are the go-to places for those who love cooking seafood at home or simply want access to the freshest options. Here’s an expanded look at some of the best markets offering high-quality fresh seafood:
One of the oldest and largest seafood markets in the United States, Fulton Fish Market has been providing fresh catches since 1822. Located in the Bronx, it offers a vast selection of fish and shellfish, both in-person and online, for home delivery.
This bustling marketplace in Manhattan is home to Lobster Place, one of NYC’s most beloved seafood vendors. From live lobsters to sushi-grade tuna and freshly shucked oysters, it’s a paradise for seafood lovers and home chefs.
Citarella is a high-end grocery store with multiple NYC locations, renowned for its top-quality fresh seafood. You’ll find various options, including wild-caught salmon, scallops, and prepared items like shrimp cocktails, ready for any occasion.
This Brooklyn-based market specializes in sustainably sourced seafood, making it a favorite among eco-conscious shoppers. They offer a curated selection of fresh fish and shellfish alongside a café that serves freshly prepared seafood dishes.
A historic market on the Lower East Side, Essex Market has been a hub for fresh ingredients for over 100 years. It features vendors selling everything from whole fish to smoked seafood, ensuring you can find something for any recipe.
This vibrant farmers’ market in Manhattan includes local seafood purveyors offering the freshest catches from nearby waters. Seasonal offerings change weekly, making it a great spot to discover new varieties of fish and shellfish.
Specialty Japanese grocery stores like Mitsuwa in New Jersey and Sunrise Mart in NYC are excellent for sourcing sushi-grade fish. They also offer unique items like uni, fresh sashimi cuts, and seafood, which are often difficult to find elsewhere.
Seafood lovers visiting or living in NYC can make the most of the city’s incredible seafood scene with a few thoughtful approaches. Here are some tips to ensure you get the best seafood experiences NYC has to offer:
Popular seafood in NYC includes oysters, lobster, crab, shrimp, and fish such as salmon and tuna. Many restaurants also feature seafood pastas, sushi, and iconic dishes like clam chowder or lobster rolls. The variety ensures there’s something for every seafood lover.
Yes, several restaurants in NYC offer seafood buffets, especially at high-end hotels or during special events. Buffets often include dishes like crab legs, shrimp, oysters, and sushi, providing a wide range of options. Be sure to check for reservations, as these buffets are often popular.
Affordable seafood options can be found at food trucks, casual seafood shacks, and restaurants with happy hour deals. Spots in neighborhoods like Queens and Brooklyn often provide fresh seafood at reasonable prices. Many markets also sell prepared seafood dishes that won’t break the bank.
NYC has adapted several seafood dishes, such as New York-style clam pizza, seafood bagels topped with lox or smoked fish, and extravagant seafood towers. Another local favorite is blackened fish tacos served with bold, flavorful seasonings. These unique creations are worth trying when in the city.
A good seafood restaurant is often identified by its reviews, freshness of the seafood, and seasonal menu options. Look for places that emphasize sustainability and have a strong reputation among locals. Visiting during busy hours can also indicate high demand and quality.
Yes, NYC has several restaurants offering all-you-can-eat sushi options. These spots typically include sushi rolls, sashimi, and appetizers for a fixed price. Popular locations for this experience can be found in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens.
Several high-end restaurants in NYC offer seafood-focused tasting menus featuring multi-course meals with curated seafood dishes. These menus might include items like caviar, lobster, oysters, or inventive preparations of seasonal fish. Reservations are often required for these exclusive experiences.
NYC offers various ways to enjoy lobster, including classic lobster rolls, whole steamed or grilled lobster, and lobster mac and cheese. Fine dining establishments also serve creative dishes like lobster ravioli or lobster bisque. For a casual experience, seafood shacks and food trucks are great options.
Yes, many seafood restaurants in NYC cater to dietary restrictions such as gluten-free, dairy-free, or low-sodium needs. Menus often highlight allergen-friendly options or allow for customization. It’s always a good idea to call ahead and confirm with the staff.
Absolutely! Markets like Fulton Fish Market, Chelsea Market, and Union Square Greenmarket provide fresh seafood for home cooking. Specialty stores and local fishmongers also offer high-quality seafood and advice on preparation techniques.
382 NE 191st ST
PMB # 884858
Miami, Florida
Contact us: support@getsauce.com