Welcome to Stromboli’s
New York Pizzeria
If you’re searching for the best pizza in Windermere, you’ve found it! At Stromboli’s New York Pizzeria, we serve authentic New York style pizza made with hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, and family recipes passed down through generations. Our pizzeria in Windermere, FL is proud to bring the bold flavors of New York right to your neighborhood.
Whether you’re craving a classic cheese slice, a hearty stromboli, or one of our signature specialty pies, we’ve got something for everyone. Families, friends, and pizza lovers from all over choose Stromboli’s because we’re more than just a restaurant — we’re a place where community comes together.
Stop by today and taste why locals call us the best pizzeria in Windermere. Dine in, carry out, or order online — no matter how you enjoy it, Stromboli’s is here to serve you the true flavor of New York.
A Slice of New York, Right Here in Windermere
At Stromboli’s, every slice is a taste of New York tradition. Our menu brings together hand-tossed pizzas with crispy thin crusts, oven-baked pastas, hearty strombolis, and fresh salads—all crafted with quality ingredients and authentic recipes. From classic cheese and pepperoni pies to specialty creations loaded with flavor, every dish is made to order and served hot from our ovens. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or sharing a full pizza with friends, Stromboli’s delivers the warmth and taste of true New York comfort food.
Our Location
Stromboli’s New York Pizzeria, Windermere, FL
Address
13518 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
Contacts
(407) 654-5291
info@nystrombolispizzeria.com
Hours
Monday-Sunday:
11:30AM–9PM
What Our Customers Are Saying
Manliff Coggan
21:32 13 Nov 25
Great pizza, I get the family vibe, highly recommend, definitely returning
Melissa Marie
15:30 13 Nov 25
I can't even begin to tell you how AMAZING their pizza is!! We probably order pickup twice a week just because we NEVER have a bad pizza. A few times we had the mozzarella sticks which are yummy and their meatballs are sweet and delicious. These guys are always working so hard so when I pop in to grab my pizza it's nice they take a moment to say hello to their "hair stylist" customer. The crust is always perfect and they put just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Prices are extremely reasonable and we always do pick up because Uber eats and doordash charge WAY too much for delivery. I'm hoping they offer a punch card soon for their pizza lover regulars. 😉
Shu Ma
01:30 13 Nov 25
Pizza is always fresh. For sure the best pizza in Windermere.
Conaway Freniere
18:14 10 Nov 25
Food came out on time and hot. The cheese pizza is the best I've had in Winter Garden.
Dana Radovanovic
02:09 09 Nov 25
Great NY style
Walter Jacobsen
18:08 07 Nov 25
Best slices in area and it's not close. They don't skimp on cheese. Always A+
David Rubin
19:33 06 Nov 25
The pizza is always excellent but today I had the chicken cutlet and spaghetti and that was equally fantastic. The kitchen always does an excellent job. The service can be great or good depending on the day, but the food is always great.
Highly recommend.
Highly recommend.
Mason Merrill
21:40 04 Nov 25
Very nice restaurant with great food and amazing pizza
Jeff (JJ)
23:48 27 Sep 25
Great place, with great pizza
Angela Caló de Mauco
19:34 23 Sep 25
The best Pizza on Windermere!
Jason Burke
23:16 21 Sep 25
The food is always incredible.
Jorge Grajales
17:55 16 Sep 25
Excellent service
Srin Tangirala
23:36 14 Sep 25
Some of the best local pizza around. Closest I’ve found to Jersey pizza.